Fulford: Israel-demonizers are Jew-hating bigots AND leftist radicals

fulfordprofile.jpg

The ever-brilliant Robert Fulford dissects the nature of the “Israel=Apartheid” propaganda movement on the march around the world in today’s National Post column, “Ms. doesn’t disappoint the left”. Well worth the five-minute read, to gain a clear understanding of where the support for the clearly absurd charge of smearing Israel with the sins of South Africa’s racist past comes from:

That crazy notion doesn’t withstand even superficial examination. Nevertheless, it has spread around the world, and the recent Israeli Apartheid Week at the University of Toronto was only one of dozens held in various countries. Alone among universities, so far as I know, McMaster in Hamilton has made a symbolic gesture of opposition to this widespread nonsense. The McMaster administration asked the anti-Israeli campaigners to take down one banner that said “Israeli Apartheid.”

Supporters of the campaign, always yearning for victim status, have predictably screamed with rage. “Our Movement Will Not Be Silenced!” says Canadian Dimension — traditionally one of the dumber leftist magazines — calling the request a “shocking decision” and an unprecedented attack on the right to free speech, academic freedom and the right to organize. Canadian Dimension also says that the Zionist movement has launched a campaign of “intimidation and repression” against students. They have put full-page ads in newspapers! Worse, the Israeli ambassador organized a public forum! Zionist groups held public meetings! Repression is everywhere.

Any outsider who attends an Israeli Apartheid meeting, as I have, soon realizes that the participants know as much about Palestinians as they know about Patagonians. What they know for sure is that they hate Israel and want it destroyed. Since that’s beyond their abilities, they want it embarrassed. They invite one or two Palestinian radicals who show up to explain that the Palestinians are right about everything and the Israelis wrong. No one questions these assertions, no one discusses anything. These are pep rallies, not conferences. We who consider free speech sacred may be made a little nervous by McMaster’s action. On the other hand, what it mildly discouraged wasn’t so much free speech as unexamined groupthink.

Anti-semitism explains some but not by any means all of this phenomenon. It seems likely to me that success is Israel’s unforgivable crime. Most of the region is a pathetic failure in economics, politics and culture. But Israel, despite titanic problems, runs a successful economy, admirable universities, a free judiciary and a free press. Leftists, committed to the view that the West is responsible for all the failures of the Third World, even including endemic dictatorship, find it impossible to tolerate such a stinging rebuke to their arguments.

From the comments section of the National Post’s web site comes this fine addition from a reader:

by Marty Mac

Feb 23 2008
3:25 PM
Your article was too kind to the organizers of the Israeli apartheid rallies.  My daughter attended one and stated that the only thing missing were the swastikas.  Why not call them what they are ,  Neo Nazis?  She went there, to perhaps get a better understanding of what was happening but only heard the usual anti Jewish rhetoric. On the other hand, Universities which are supposed to be centers where the free exchange of ideas, should allow these rallies as long as they permit those holding opposing views the same opportunity.  Sadly, that is not the case any more due to the politicalization and intolerance of many in the academic world, a trend that is entered the publishing world with increasing frequency.

The sick, disturbing alliance of anti-semites, Islamic Jihad, and the academic left…rearing its ugly head once again, with an intensity not seen since a similar alliance of anti-semites, national-socialist-chauvinists, and the academic left in Europe in the 1930s.

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Islamist-Leftist Alliance, Jew-Hatred in Canada, Left-Wing Causes Celebre, Youth Indoctrination

One response to “Fulford: Israel-demonizers are Jew-hating bigots AND leftist radicals

  1. Heh heh, the joy of free speech is that we get to mock their idiocy. The same lefties/ anti-zionists who claim McMaster was attempting to silence them would likely express strong support for the administration if McMaster had torn down a Pro-Life banner.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s