Tory on Religious Schools: A winner in the end

Could John Tory have picked a better wedge issue on which to fight the Ontario election? Yes. Could he have chosen a better proposal on educational reform, like a charter school program? Certainly. Is John Tory’s platform conservative? Not at all. But Christina Blizzard of the Toronto Sun has me convinced: the religious school funding issue will be, in the end, a political winner for Tory, and possibly a fatal blow to Dalton McGuinty’s re-election prospects.

Blizzard’s column today exposes the astounding hypicricy, illogic, and foolish politics of McGuinty’s battle against the Tory proposal. After eviscerating McGuinty for using Catholic school children as election campaign props yesterday morning, and pointing out once again that McGuinty was raised in Catholic schools, sends his kids to Catholic schools, and has a wife who teaches in a Catholic school, she makes this prescient political observation:

What is most troubling is the tone of McGuinty’s attack on private religious schools. He seems to imply they are somehow inferior.

I don’t think Jewish, Hindu or Muslim parents are going to make the kind of financial sacrifices necessary to keep their kids in private religious school if they weren’t getting results.

No, I think this issue is turning on McGuinty. It is insulting for people of other faiths to be told their religious schools threaten the social fabric — but Catholic schools don’t.

In the final analysis, Ontario voters will be forced to choose Tory’s least-bad option: let Catholic schools keep their funding, but offer equal support to other faiths. McGuinty’s ludicrous support for the status quo is, without a doubt, a worse option to most reasonable voters.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Ontario Politics, The Sinking Ship Liberal

2 responses to “Tory on Religious Schools: A winner in the end

  1. emil

    I would have voted Conservative, but I won’t. I agree with your (and the Sun’s columnist) point that McGuinty is hypocritical, but I am totally opposed to Muslim schools funded by public money. And secondly, I think that an equal measure of opportunism applies to John Tory. His pandering to the Muslim vote is disgusting. There was no need to turn this into an election issue, and the true rationale behind it has more to do with trying to appease the multi-culti crowd than with conservative principles. Anyway, I’m quite curious how things will play out in my Scarborough riding, where there is a sizeable Muslim constituency and a Liberal incumbent. Should I dare suggest who would cheer most after a PC victory? Quite ironic, but what can you expect when the leader of the Ontario Conservatives is a moron.

  2. emil

    What I would have expected from a Conservative was to address this issue:
    http://www.economist.com/displayStory.cfm?Story_ID=9804671

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s